What is the punishment of anyone who changes the will of a deceased person?

ما هو جزاء الإنسان الذي يغير وصية شخص متوفى؟

In Islamic law, once a testator issues a valid and fair will, it becomes a binding right that cannot be altered or modified. Anyone who intentionally changes, adds to, or subtracts from the will bears a grave sin, while the deceased still receives their full spiritual reward.

في الشريعة الإسلامية، بمجرد أن يصدر الموصي وصية صحيحة وعادلة، فإنها تصبح حقاً ملزماً لا يجوز تغييره أو تعديله. وأي شخص يتعمد تغيير الوصية أو الزيادة عليها أو النقصان منها يتحمل إثماً عظيماً، بينما ينال المتوفى أجره الروحي كاملاً.

Fulfilling the final wishes of the deceased is a sacred trust in Islam, protected by severe divine warnings against tampering or distortion.

إن تنفيذ الوصية الأخيرة للمتوفى أمانة مقدسة في الإسلام، تحميها تحذيرات إلهية شديدة من العبث أو التحريف.

The Sanctity of the Will | حرمة الوصية

1. A Binding Right
If the will is issued by the testator, it is a binding right that may not be changed or altered, unless the will itself is unfair or unlawful.
1. حق ملزم
إذا صدرت الوصية عن الموصي كانت حقا واجبا لا يجوز تغييره و لا تبديله، إلا إذا كانت الوصية غير عادلة.

2. The Sin of Alteration
Whoever alters the will, distorts it, adds to it, or reduces it, the sin of this alteration falls entirely on those who make the change. Allah will hold them accountable for their actions, while the deceased is fully rewarded for their original good intention.
2. إثم التبديل
فمن بدل الوصية أو حرفها و زاد عليها أو أنقصها، فإثم التبديل يقع على الذين يقومون بتغيير الوصية، وَيُجَازِيهِمْ الله على نياتهم و عملهم. و يقع أجر الوصية على الميت.

3. The Divine Warning
(But whoever changes the will after hearing it, the blame will only be on those who made the change. Indeed, Allah is All Hearing, All Knowing.) Al Baqara 2: 181.
3. التحذير الإلهي
(فَمَن بَدَّلَهُ بَعْدَ مَا سَمِعَهُ فَإِنَّمَا إِثْمُهُ عَلَى الَّذِينَ يُبَدِّلُونَهُ ۚ إِنَّ اللَّهَ سَمِيعٌ عَلِيمٌ ‎‏) البقرة 2: 181.

Scholarly Insight: In Islamic Jurisprudence, protecting a will from tampering is considered a major obligation. Scholars agree that the executor of the will is acting as a trustee holding a massive responsibility. If the executor or the heirs maliciously hide, destroy, or rewrite the document to favor certain people, they are committing a major sin similar to stealing an orphan's wealth. The only exception mentioned by scholars is if the original will contained a clear injustice, such as leaving more than one third of the estate or giving an extra share to a legal heir. In such cases of error or injustice, correcting the will to align with Sharia is actually required, as mentioned in the subsequent verse of Surah Al Baqara.

Frequently Asked Questions | الأسئلة الشائعة

Does the deceased lose their reward if the heirs change the will?

No. The deceased is rewarded based on their original, sincere intention when they wrote the will. The sin and punishment fall entirely on the living people who altered it.

Are there any situations where changing a will is allowed?

Yes. If the original will contains a clear mistake, an injustice, or a violation of Islamic law like giving more than one third of the estate to a charity, the executor or a judge must correct it to match the limits of the Sharia.

What should a witness do if they see the will being changed illegally?

A witness has a religious duty to speak the truth and prevent the injustice. Concealing the truth or allowing the distortion to happen makes the witness a partner in the sin.

Chapter 4.2 - Financial Matters

Previous Question