Is It Better to Give Charity Publicly or Secretly?
أيهما أفضل في الصدقة: السر أم الإعلان؟
It is permissible to give charity both secretly or in public. ‘ To give charity publicly is good, but to give to the poor privately is better for you, and will absolve you of your sins.’ Al-Baqara 2:271
Being discreet about giving to charity is better than doing it publicly because that is further from showing off. Our Prophet, peace be upon him, said: “There are seven whom Allah will shade with His shade on the day when there will be no shade except His ” and he mentioned among them: “a man who gives in charity and conceals it to an extent that his left-hand does not know what his right hand gives.” (Agreed upon, narrated by al-Bukhaari, no. 1423; Muslim, no. 1031; and others)
Note: The earlier published text gave this hadith the numbers 620 in al-Bukhari and 1712 in Muslim, which are other hadiths; it is 1423 in al-Bukhari and 1031 in Muslim, and so they were corrected.
There is an exception: when giving charity publicly brings a greater benefit, such as encouraging other people to do the same; then in that case, giving it publicly is better in that respect. So the good intentions the person has when he gives his charity in public may make it better than giving in secret, making sure that the intentions are not tainted by Satan's whispering, and guarding against showing off, self-admiration and anything else that diminishes or nullifies the reward of the good deed.
أولاً: يجوز الإسرار بالصدقة كما يجوز الإعلان بها، كما قال تعالى: "إِن تُبْدُوا الصَّدَقَاتِ فَنِعِمَّا هِيَ ۖ وَإِن تُخْفُوهَا وَتُؤْتُوهَا الْفُقَرَاءَ".
ثانيًا: إسرار الصدقة أفضل من إظهارها؛ لأن ذلك أبعد من الرياء، قال نبينا ﷺ: "سبعة يظلهم الله في ظله يوم لا ظل إلا ظله..." وذكر منهم: "ورجل تصدق بصدقة فأخفاها حتى لا تعلم شماله ما تنفق يمينه".
ملاحظة: جاء في الترجمة الإنجليزية المنشورة سابقا رقم هذا الحديث 620 عند البخاري و1712 عند مسلم، وهما حديثان آخران، والصواب 1423 عند البخاري و1031 عند مسلم، فصحح الرقمان.
ويستثنى من ذلك: أن يترتب على الإظهار مصلحة راجحة، كاقتداء الناس به، فيكون أفضل من هذه الحيثية. فما قصده المتصدق من المقاصد الحسنة في إظهاره الصدقة قد يجعل إظهارها أفضل من إخفائها مع الحرص على سد مداخل الشيطان، والحذر من الرياء والعجب، وغير ذلك مما يحبط الأجر أو ينقص.
1. Both Are Good | كلاهما خير
Allah says: To give charity publicly is good, but to give to the poor privately is better for you (2:271). Ibn Kathir explains the first as: if you give it openly, it is an excellent thing. He takes from the second that giving secretly is better than giving openly, because it is further from showing off, unless giving openly brings a greater benefit, such as people following the giver’s example; then it is better in that respect.
قال الله تعالى: (إِن تُبْدُوا الصَّدَقَاتِ فَنِعِمَّا هِيَ ۖ وَإِن تُخْفُوهَا وَتُؤْتُوهَا الْفُقَرَاءَ فَهُوَ خَيْرٌ لَّكُمْ) (البقرة 2: 271). قال ابن كثير: «أي: إن أظهرتموها فنعم شيء هي». وقال في قوله تعالى: (وإن تخفوها وتؤتوها الفقراء فهو خير لكم): «فيه دلالة على أن إسرار الصدقة أفضل من إظهارها؛ لأنه أبعد عن الرياء، إلا أن يترتب على الإظهار مصلحة راجحة، من اقتداء الناس به، فيكون أفضل من هذه الحيثية».
2. Hidden From His Left Hand | حتى لا تعلم شماله
The Prophet said: There are seven whom Allah will shade with His shade on the day when there is no shade but His, and he named among them: a man who gives charity and hides it, so that his left hand does not know what his right hand spends (Sahih al-Bukhari 1423). See the reward for donating in Allah’s cause.
قال النبي صلى الله عليه وسلم: «سبعة يظلهم الله تعالى في ظله يوم لا ظل إلا ظله ... ورجل تصدق بصدقة فأخفاها حتى لا تعلم شماله ما تنفق يمينه» (صحيح البخاري 1423).
3. When Giving Openly Is Better | حين يكون الإظهار أفضل
Jarir ibn Abdullah said: Some Bedouins wearing wool came to the Messenger of Allah, and he saw their poor state, that need had struck them. He urged people to give charity, and they were slow, until that showed on his face. Then a man from the Ansar brought a purse of silver, then another came, and they followed one after another, until joy showed on his face. The Messenger of Allah said: Whoever sets a good practice in Islam, and it is acted on after him, will have recorded for him the like of the reward of those who act on it, with nothing reduced from their rewards (Sahih Muslim 1017).
قال جرير بن عبد الله رضي الله عنه: «جاء ناس من الأعراب إلى رسول الله صلى الله عليه وسلم عليهم الصوف فرأى سوء حالهم قد أصابتهم حاجة فحث الناس على الصدقة فأبطئوا عنه حتى رئي ذلك في وجهه - قال - ثم إن رجلا من الأنصار جاء بصرة من ورق ثم جاء آخر ثم تتابعوا حتى عرف السرور في وجهه فقال رسول الله صلى الله عليه وسلم: من سن في الإسلام سنة حسنة فعمل بها بعده كتب له مثل أجر من عمل بها ولا ينقص من أجورهم شيء» (صحيح مسلم 1017).
Scholarly Insight: Giving in secret carries a further promise: Allah says that it will absolve you of your sins (2:271). Ibn Kathir explains that charity, especially when it is secret, brings you good in the raising of ranks, and removes your sins. Read more in the tafsir of Surah Al-Baqarah.
Frequently Asked Questions | الأسئلة الشائعة
Which is better: to give charity publicly or secretly?
Both are permissible. Giving secretly is generally better, because it is further from showing off (2:271), unless giving openly brings a greater benefit, such as others following the example.
When is giving publicly better?
When it brings a greater benefit, such as encouraging other people to do the same; then it is better in that respect, as long as the giver guards against showing off and self-admiration.
What did the Prophet say about hiding charity?
He named among the seven whom Allah will shade a man who gives charity and hides it, so that his left hand does not know what his right hand spends (Sahih al-Bukhari 1423).
What could spoil charity given publicly?
Satan’s whispering, showing off and self-admiration, which can diminish or nullify the reward of the good deed.
Prepared by Eng. Ghada Homad, founder of IslamFAQ, researched and written in consultation with qualified scholars, reviewed by Professor Khaled Jassem Al-Houli, Associate Professor of Comparative Jurisprudence and Islamic Politics, Faculty of Sharia and Islamic Studies, University of Kuwait. Read more about the authors and this project →